Sports Knee Surgery

Meniscus Tears & Preservation

The menisci are essential for knee stability, shock absorption and protecting the joint cartilage. Meniscus injuries are common, particularly during sports involving twisting and pivoting movements, but they can also develop gradually over time. Not every meniscus tear requires surgery. When surgery is appropriate, preserving and repairing the meniscus wherever possible is a priority for maintaining long-term knee function.

Understanding the Meniscus

Each knee has two menisci: the medial meniscus on the inside and the lateral meniscus on the outside.

These C-shaped structures of fibrocartilage sit between the thighbone (femur) and shinbone (tibia). They help distribute load, absorb shock, stabilise the knee and protect the joint surfaces.

The outer portion of each meniscus has a better blood supply than the inner portion, which influences its ability to heal. However, modern repair techniques mean that selected tears extending into less vascular areas may still be repairable.

Knee anatomy showing the medial and lateral menisci, cruciate ligaments and meniscal blood supply.

Types of Meniscus Tears

Meniscus tears vary in their shape, location, severity and potential for healing.

Common patterns include longitudinal, bucket-handle, radial, horizontal, flap, parrot-beak and complex tears.

Some tears remain stable, while others may displace and interfere with normal knee movement. A displaced bucket-handle tear, for example, can cause the knee to become mechanically locked.

The tear pattern alone does not determine treatment. Tissue quality, symptoms, associated injuries and the condition of the surrounding cartilage are equally important.

Illustration of common meniscus tear patterns including longitudinal, radial, bucket-handle, flap, complex and horizontal tears.

Meniscal Root Tears

The meniscal roots anchor the menisci to the tibia and are essential for converting compressive forces into circumferential tension.

A complete root tear can substantially compromise the meniscus's ability to distribute load, increasing pressure on the joint cartilage.

In appropriately selected patients, arthroscopic root repair aims to restore the meniscus's attachment and function.

Not all root tears benefit from surgery, particularly where advanced cartilage degeneration (osteoarthritis) is present.

Superior view of the knee showing the medial and lateral menisci and their root attachments.

Symptoms & Diagnosis

Common symptoms include joint-line pain, swelling, catching, discomfort with twisting or squatting, and occasionally locking.

Diagnosis begins with a clinical assessment. MRI helps identify the tear pattern, location and associated ligament or cartilage injuries.

Importantly, meniscal abnormalities on MRI do not always cause symptoms, particularly in patients with degenerative changes.

Treatment Options

Non-Surgical Treatment

Many stable and degenerative meniscal tears can be treated without surgery.

Management may include physiotherapy, progressive strengthening, activity modification and appropriate symptom relief. Treatment focuses on restoring movement, improving muscular control and returning to normal activities.

Meniscus Repair

When appropriate, arthroscopic meniscus repair aims to preserve the patient's own meniscal tissue and restore its function.

Modern repair techniques allow many tear patterns to be repaired, including selected complex, radial and meniscal root tears.


Biological Augmentation with Autologous Blood Clot

Biological augmentation with an autologous blood clot is an emerging technique used to support healing, particularly in complex meniscal tears. The blood clot provides a biological scaffold that may enhance tissue repair. Such augmentation might be considered in high risk tears in young patients, re-repairs or any tears with compromised blood supply and lower healing chance.

Partial Meniscectomy

When a tear cannot be reliably repaired and is causing significant symptoms, a limited partial meniscectomy may be appropriate.

The aim is to remove only unstable, non-functioning tissue while preserving as much healthy meniscus as possible.

Meniscal debridement is not routinely recommended for degenerative tears, particularly where symptoms are primarily related to osteoarthritis.

Why Meniscus Preservation Matters

Removing meniscal tissue reduces the knee's ability to distribute load and can increase contact pressures on the joint cartilage.

Preserving a functioning meniscus may help protect long-term joint health, although successful repair cannot guarantee prevention of osteoarthritis.

My approach considers the entire knee, including ligament stability, alignment, cartilage health and individual activity requirements, rather than focusing on the meniscal tear in isolation.

Anatomical illustration highlighting the medial and lateral menisci within the knee joint.

Recovery & Rehabilitation

Rehabilitation depends on the treatment performed and the complexity of the injury.

Following a partial meniscectomy, weight-bearing and movement can often progress relatively quickly.

Following meniscus repair, rehabilitation is generally more protective. Weight-bearing, knee flexion and loading restrictions will be required while the repair heals.

Return to sport is guided by healing, strength, movement quality and functional progression rather than time alone. Complex repairs and root repairs typically require longer rehabilitation.

Frequently Asked Questions

ON THIS PAGE

No headings found on page