Sports Knee Surgery
ACL & Knee Ligament Injuries
The knee relies on several ligaments working together to provide stability during everyday movement, running, pivoting and sport. An ACL injury may occur in isolation, but injuries to the meniscus, cartilage or other knee ligaments are common. Understanding the complete injury pattern is important when deciding whether treatment should involve rehabilitation, surgery or a combination of both.
Understanding the Knee Ligaments
The knee ligaments work together to control forward, backward, sideways and rotational movement.
PCL — Posterior cruciate ligament
The PCL is the other major cruciate ligament. It primarily limits backward movement of the tibia (shinbone) and contributes to overall knee stability.
MCL & medial structures
The MCL and associated medial structures stabilise the inner side of the knee. Many isolated MCL injuries heal without surgery and without significant residual laxity. The injury pattern becomes particularly important when the ACL or other ligaments are also injured.
LCL & posterolateral corner
The LCL and posterolateral corner help stabilise the outer side of the knee and control abnormal sideways and rotational movement. These structures are particularly important to recognise in combined or multiligament knee injuries.
Symptoms & Diagnosis
How ACL injuries occur
ACL injuries commonly occur during pivoting, landing or sudden changes of direction. Some occur through direct contact.
Symptoms & associated injuries
Patients may describe a pop, rapid swelling or difficulty continuing activity. After the initial injury settles, recurrent giving way or a feeling that the knee cannot be trusted during twisting or sport may become the main problem.
An ACL injury can also involve meniscus tears, cartilage or osteochondral injury, MCL or other ligament injury, and bone bruising. These associated injuries can influence treatment and rehabilitation.
Meniscus tears commonly occur with ACL injuries. Where a tear is repairable, preserving the meniscus is generally preferable to removing functioning meniscal tissue. A successfully repaired meniscus can contribute to knee stability and support the outcome of ACL reconstruction. Whether repair is possible depends on factors including the tear pattern, location and tissue quality.
Assessment & imaging
Assessment includes the history of the injury, current symptoms and a clinical examination to assess knee stability and associated injuries.
An MRI is obtained following a suspected ACL injury to confirm the diagnosis and assess the meniscus, cartilage and other knee ligaments.
An X-ray may also be performed initially, particularly to exclude a fracture or assess the bony anatomy.
Ultrasound has no useful role in assessing an ACL injury.
A knee effusion following an acute injury warrants timely investigation. In my practice, I recommend a timely MRI following an acute knee injury associated with an effusion. MRI helps identify important internal knee injuries — including ligament, meniscal, cartilage and osteochondral injuries — and allows appropriate treatment decisions to be made early. An abnormal MRI does not necessarily mean surgery is required. Treatment depends on the injury identified, symptoms, knee stability and activity requirements.
In revision ACL reconstruction or more complex ligament injuries, additional imaging may be required to assess previous bone tunnels, alignment or other factors relevant to reconstruction.
A suspected knee dislocation, new numbness or weakness, or signs of impaired circulation require urgent emergency assessment.
Treatment Options
Non-operative treatment
Some people can regain good function with structured rehabilitation, particularly when the knee is functionally stable and their activities do not require frequent pivoting or directional change. Non-operative treatment is undertaken in conjunction with a physiotherapist and, where appropriate, a sports physician. Regular communication with the treating team allows progress, knee stability and return to activity to be monitored.
When surgery may be considered
If instability or inability to trust the knee persist despite rehabilitation, ACL reconstruction should then be considered. ACL reconstruction should also be considered when returning to activities that require a stable pivoting knee, or when associated injuries influence the decision. The decision depends on the injury pattern, symptoms, how stable the knee feels and performs, activity requirements and the individual.
ACL Reconstruction
ACL reconstruction aims to restore stability by replacing the torn ligament with a graft. Associated meniscus, cartilage or other ligament injuries may need to be addressed at the same time. Rehabilitation is an essential part of treatment and aims to restore movement, strength, neuromuscular control and confidence in the knee.
The source page also identifies primary ACL reconstruction, revision ACL reconstruction, meniscus repair and combined ligament reconstruction as procedures that may form part of care, depending on the injury pattern.
Choosing the Right Graft
The choice of graft is an important part of ACL reconstruction. Age, sporting demands, individual anatomy and previous surgery all influence the decision. Each graft has advantages and limitations, and the most appropriate option is discussed with the patient.
Commonly Used Autografts
Hamstring Tendon — A commonly used graft with low rates of anterior knee and kneeling discomfort. Potential considerations include hamstring strength and graft size.
Bone–Patellar Tendon–Bone (BTB) — Provides bone-to-bone fixation and is an established option for high-demand athletes. Anterior knee pain and kneeling discomfort are relevant considerations.
Quadriceps Tendon — A versatile graft with favourable graft dimensions. Potential donor-site symptoms and quadriceps weakness are considerations during recovery.
Lateral Extra-Articular Tenodesis (LET)
LET is an additional procedure performed on the outer side of the knee alongside ACL reconstruction. It can improve rotational stability and reduce the risk of graft failure in selected patients.
It may be considered particularly in younger patients returning to pivoting sports, those with high-grade rotational instability, generalised ligamentous laxity, or patients undergoing revision ACL reconstruction.
The decision is based on the overall injury pattern and individual risk factors.
Revision ACL Reconstruction
If a previous ACL reconstruction has failed, simply replacing the graft may not be enough. Understanding why it failed is essential to planning further treatment.
Revision surgery can be more complex than the first reconstruction. Depending on the findings, it may be possible to complete the procedure in one operation, while some patients require a staged approach.
What Needs to Be Considered?
Other Knee Ligament Injuries
The ligaments around the knee work together to provide stability. Injuries may involve one or several ligaments, and not all require surgery.
Rehabilitation & Return to Sport
Rehabilitation begins immediately after ACL reconstruction and progresses according to recovery of movement, strength and function.
01 · Early Recovery
Restore active full knee extension, control swelling, regain quadriceps activation and normalise walking.
02 · Strength & Movement
Progress lower-limb strength, neuromuscular control, balance and movement quality.
03 · Running & Sports Preparation
Running, jumping, landing and sport-specific activity are introduced progressively once appropriate clinical and functional milestones have been achieved.
04 · Return-to-Sport Testing
Before returning to pivoting sport, my ACL patients undergo objective assessment with a qualified physiotherapist. Testing considers strength, functional performance, movement quality, sport-specific capacity and psychological readiness. Return to sport is based on meeting appropriate criteria rather than time alone. Objective testing supports safer return-to-sport decision-making and aims to reduce the risk of reinjury.
Rehabilitation may differ substantially when ACL reconstruction is combined with meniscus repair, osteotomy or additional ligament reconstruction. The rehabilitation plan therefore reflects the procedures performed.
When to Seek Specialist Assessment
Specialist assessment is appropriate if you experience:
• An acute knee injury with significant swelling or suspected ligament damage.
• Recurrent instability, particularly when the knee gives way during everyday activities or sport.
• Difficulty returning to sport despite rehabilitation.
• Persistent symptoms following previous ACL surgery, or a new injury to a reconstructed knee.
An ACL injury does not always require surgery. Specialist assessment can help clarify the injury and determine the most appropriate treatment.
